Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
30 May 2017
Will a new Staples CMO make a lick of difference?
This is not an open letter to Michelle Bottomley, the newly hired Staples CMO. Those tend to be trite. But if there’s a time for Bottomley and the Staples leadership to listen to reason, it’s now.
Bottomley, the global CMO of human resources consulting firm Mercer, is taking the job after the previous Staples CMO, Frank Bifulco, announced his retirement. It also comes on the heels of a failed merger with Office Depot, declining sales and a stock price that’s dipped 31 percent over the last five years.
“No, Staples must be different. If it keeps looking and sounding like an office supply store, it’s dead.”
In other words, times are tough for Staples and its ilk. In fact, that’s the problem. The ilk of Staples, Office Depot and all the other office supply stores are all basically the same. You couldn’t slip a piece of paper in between their differences. That’s why, even if the Staples Office Depot merger went through, it wouldn’t have made a lick of difference. Already, consumers think they are the same.
The new Staples CMO must make the brand truly different
What’s lacking in this industry is simple differentiation. Sure, there have been attempts. But none of them have resonated with audiences. Office Depot tested a “store of the future” in Nevada that went nowhere. (It also laid out a campaign telling audience that it has stamps. Like anyone sends letters anymore.)
In a vacuum, that’s an appropriate strategy. Office supply stores are, in fact, for offices, right? But that doesn’t make Staples any different than Office Depot or, for that matter, FedEx Office.
Bottomley and Staples CEO Shira Goodman need to think bigger. They need to revolutionize the office supply business, which probably means fewer stores and a stronger online presence.
More importantly they must align themselves with the single most emotional trigger among target audiences within context of who they when they use the Staples brand. You could argue that, today, those audiences describe themselves as a pro, judging by the latest advertising campaign.
That, though, is not all the emotional and probably isn’t the most persuasive argument for shopping at Staples. No, Staples must be different. If it keeps looking and sounding like an office supply store, it’s dead.
MoviePass Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 15 August 2018 MoviePass - the great idea till it wasn’t MoviePass is quickly dying. Its stock is now at five cents a share. It seemed like a great idea. Though, in retrospect, it served only as a great...
Hulu Originals Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 14 August 2018 Hulu Originals create preference, Netflix diminishes returns Like many, I’ve cut my cable cord because, in part, the variety of affordable steaming options made my need for a multitude of cable...
Overstock brand Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 13 August 2018 The sheer lunacy of the Overstock brand What’s in a brand name? If you consider the Overstock brand, you see a very confused one resulting in an online retailer getting crushed by Amazon. If you’ve...