The problem with the Vader kid spot
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
7 February 2011
Entertaining as hell, but it does nothing for Volkswagen
OK, the Volkswagen spot with the Vader kid was cute, but it was still like every other commercial that aired during the Super Bowl: It wasn’t linked to the brand itself.
There are many Monday morning quarterbacks eager to go over which ad was the funniest or most remembered or what other scorecard they want to use, and I’m not going to do that here.
I’m also not going to go in great detail about whether it’s strategically smart to advertise during the Super Bowl (it’s not) or wonder how all those automobile manufacturers could think they’re only problem is awareness so they saturated the ad time.
“I love watching that Vader kid, but, in the end, he creates no preference for me because I had to wait for the pundits to tell me who the ad was for. The ad itself didn’t.”
No, the single biggest problem in the advertising industry is that most of them basically follow this outline: Comedy skit, plus logo. As much as I love the Volkswagen spot in other ways – it is beautifully done, with an exquisite sense of timing and tone – it is symptomatic of this problem.
The Vader kid spot doesn’t get you to prefer Volkswagen and it doesn’t even raise the level of awareness of the brand, as if that was Volkswagen’s problem. The only thing you see at the end of the spot is: “The all new Passat.” There is simply no connection to the brand, or even the product. I’ll bet most of you didn’t even know it was marketing the Passat.
In fact, after that spot aired and our laughter died down, I waited a few minutes, then asked those watching with me, “Who was that spot for?” No one could remember.
I have often railed against the advertising-as-entertainment trend and believe getting caught in the “who can top whom” competition that is Super Bowl advertising is a huge waste of money.
But it is also represents a larger problem with advertising, which is why marketers are desperately trying to find other ways to reach target audiences and make their brands more meaningful to them. They have mostly given up on the print ad model and instead are constantly searching for ways to make social media work for them.
Yet, it’s all so simple and not some Jedi mind trick. The avenue isn’t as important as a message that’s tied into the promise of the brand and who it reflects. Instead, we just remember the comedy and not the brand.
Marketing is a business venture, but so few execute it that way. (That’s why an advertising agency can’t fix your problem.) I love watching that Vader kid, but, in the end, he creates no preference for me because I had to wait for the pundits to tell me who the ad was for. The ad itself didn’t.
Whole Foods 365 Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 15 January 2019 The reasons why Whole Foods 365 died If nothing else, you have to give it up to Whole Foods for seeing its mistake and not making it worse. The grocery chain announces it's discontinuing Whole...
Retail market changes Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 6 December 2018 Retail market changes are akin to climate change Are you paying attention to the many retail market changes? I am. Some fundamental changes are afoot. I believe the days of large generalized...
Prime Day Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 17 July 2018 Prime Day remains the tops, despite glitches There are very few shopping events that get me excited. Let me rephrase that. There is only one shopping event that gets me excited — Amazon’s Prime Day. Even...