Staples stores closing is the writing on the wall for all retail
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
6 March 2014
Retail has a major problem – what to do with all those stores
More than 200 Staples stores will be closed across North America. According to reports, this is being done to trim costs as more and more of the office superstore’s sales move to online.
Stay tuned, as this is just the beginning
“You are going to find banks, malls, retailers, specialty shops and gift stores all facing the same problem.”
Staples stores and the 800 Pound Amazon Gorilla
Retail marketing is beginning the sea change as more and more retailers are beginning to understand that the brick and mortar locations, once a positive equity to their bottom line, now look a lot more like the world’s most expensive billboards.
Today, you are seeing it reflected in office supplies (Places like Staples stores). But mark my word, the worm has turned and the customer has changed permanently.
What does all this mean? Well, it spells big trouble for everyone in retail from shoes, clothing and all the way to paperclips. Can the Staples stores compete effectively with Amazon? Absolutely not. And here is why.
Amazon does not need to be profitable to succeed. It may come as a surprise to many that, in all of the years that Amazon has been around rewriting the retail landscape, it has NEVER turned a profit. Yet its stock remains one of the Wall Street Darlings.
Amazon Plays a Different Game than Staples Stores
Amazon is in a different game and is playing by different rules. It is not a business in the usual sense. It is a logistics company whose value is propped up by gamblers (read investors) who are betting the ranch and the dog on a pyramid scheme that continues to self-propagate as long as Amazon’s market share continues to grow.
But in this case, preference is simply not in lock step with that market share growth. All Amazon needs to do is grab more and more of the online business without regard for profitability and its fortunes will soar. Ask Staples what it means when profits lag. Ten percent of Staples stores close, that’s what.
Amazon needs to work on its brand.
It needs to grab and hold onto an emotional place in our minds and hearts, and transition itself from an amalgamator of distributed goods to a more perfect alignment with our own self-definition as a 21st century shopper. Is “I got it on Amazon” beginning to mean something generic like “I bought it online?” The closer these two statements come together, the more Wall Street will love Amazon and the closer it comes to having its shell game come crashing down.
The poor Staples Stores. They have to compete with a competitor whose feet are never held to the fire and whose success is judged by a different standard. A standard that unfairly favors the anointed.
You heard it here first. This is just the beginning. You are going to find banks, malls, retailers, specialty shops and gift stores all facing the same problem. They will all be in the same boat as the Staples Stores. What do we do with all of these LOCATIONS?
Target stores Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 23 October 2017 Remodeling Target stores a tiny step that does little Cheers for more Target stores! Or at least, that encompasses the remarks by Target CEO Brian Cornell at a media event last week. Target spends part...
Infiniti advertising is criminal Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 19 October 2017 Infiniti advertising fails on many levels The latest Infiniti advertising leaves me cold. Strike that. It makes me heated. Not that I have anything against Infinity as a brand. It...
Coach becomes Tapestry Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 October 2017 Who cares Coach is becoming Tapestry? Coach changing its name to Tapestry means nothing no matter what CEO Victor Luis says. He tells The New York Times that the iconic leather bag company is...