Oh Sears brand, you continue to infuriate me
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
26 August 2013
Sears needs to think of its brands as one
Now we know what’s wrong with the Sears brand, and it’s even worse than I thought.
The failing company – and, more importantly, a perpetually lost brand – has put its sub-brands (Craftsman, Kenmore and DieHard) under agency review separately from the parent brand itself. It’s as if McDonald’s put its apple pie account under review, thinking it is just as important (or more) as the parent brand.
It’s insane and demonstrates that Sears thinks backward. It believes the reason it has its lowest market share in the company’s history is because the sub-brands aren’t holding up their end. True, those sales have crash-landed – sales fell 6.3% last quarter – but that’s not because the sub-brands are failing to attract customers.
“But that’s why this agency review is so mind-boggling. Any messaging/brand should be done hand-in-hand with the parent brand, not separately.”
It’s because the Sears brand is keeping them away.
The brand has been struggling for years, and for many reasons. It practically invented the appliance industry in the post-war years, serving as a precursor to malls where you could buy many different brands during your trip.
When the malls arrived, it was left with a ton of real estate but kept to the same model. It made sure the only place to get Craftsman, Kenmore and DieHard was/is at Sears.
But that’s why this agency review is so mind-boggling. Any messaging/brand should be done hand-in-hand with the parent brand, not separately. The problem is the Sears brand itself. If you have to go to Sears to buy those brands, most would whack themselves in the face with a stick rather than walk through those doors.
If Sears doesn’t think it has a problem with the Sears brand itself, then I suggest an experiment. Offer the sub-brands in another store. Give Lowe’s a call. Watch what happens. My bet is the sales of those appliances will skyrocket and the company’s brass would wonder what the hell happened.
Spotify devices Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 21 February 2018 Spotify should be making devices I arrived late as an Apple Music subscriber. But before then, I counted myself an avid user of the Spotify platform. Why did I switch? Because Apple Music integrates...
Winter Olympics Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 20 February 2018 Are you finding the Winter Olympics...boring? Are you watching the Winter Olympics? I’ve been watching my share because usually I love the Olympics. But I’ve got to say. These Games have been, well,...
Parkland shooting Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 19 February 2018 Parkland shooting survivors call us all out It’s pretty easy criticizing Millennials. You know, they’re lazy. Have no work ethic. Growing up in the age of the iPhone, they pay attention less than a...