Kmart ad intrigues, but it won’t save the retailer
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
18 November 2013
New Kmart ad positions itself against the market, but a new model is needed
Are retailers evil? That’s what a new Kmart ad wants you to think. That is, it wants you to think the other retailers are evil because they put restrictions on layaways.
In the new Kmart ad, a committee of evil people (Satan, the guy who eats the last donut, etc.) thinks of limitations to layaway, while a nun appears at the end to tell you to shop at Kmart for the forces of good.
“Kmart was the retailer most affected by the rise of Walmart, which promises lower prices so you can live a better life. Kmart just promised low prices without the emotional quotient, leading it to become irrelevant to most consumers.”
It’s a humorous ad, nothing that by itself will reverse Kmart’s fortunes or even make a dent in the holiday shopping season. But it piqued my interest because the fall of Kmart as a brand has always fascinated me. Its continued attempts, while at times enchanting, are fruitless.
Kmart was the retailer most affected by the rise of Walmart, which promises lower prices so you can live a better life. Kmart just promised low prices without the emotional quotient, leading it to become irrelevant to most consumers.
What is Kmart to do? It must change its model. Right now, it is looked on as Walmart’s little brother. Anything Kmart does – opening up its offerings, etc. – Walmart either follows up with its own version or does it in the first place. As the market leader, Walmart is the default choice when everything is equal.
Kmart’s tagline at the end of the new spot says, “Get in. Get more.” But that just sounds likes Walmart’s “Save Money. Live Better.”
No, Kmart needs to get out of its rut by becoming something completely different. Since it was a more powerful retailer, we’ve seen the rise of online shopping, Apple Stores that are a direct reflection of its “Think Different” brand and retailers trying to beat Walmart by aping Walmart.
Kmart may not be evil, but convincing audiences that the rest are evil when Kmart is just the same (minus, apparently, more lax layaway options) isn’t going to do the trick. A whole different model, not seen before in the retail industry, is what’s called for here.
Quora Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 21 August 2018 Quora gets online etiquette right I have long found issue with online public discourse, namely with interactions on Twitter. It seems users can tweet anything outlandish (see: Alex Jones) and it'll be...
Advertising mistake Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 20 August 2018 Advertising mistake colors me shocked If you’ve ever been on a TV advertising set, you see the careful craft that goes into everything. No matter how inane the ad might be. That’s why any...
MoviePass Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 15 August 2018 MoviePass - the great idea till it wasn’t MoviePass is quickly dying. Its stock is now at five cents a share. It seemed like a great idea. Though, in retrospect, it served only as a great...