Has the Oreo brand become diluted?

Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share

21 October 2011

How many kinds of Oreos do we need?

As I’ve stated before, I have a terrible weakness when it comes to junk food. Incidentally, the Oreo cookie, with its wonderfully delicious chocolaty wafer and vanilla crème center, once ranked on my highest tier of saccharin goodness.

As a child, I was a fan of pulling my Oreo cookies apart and savoring the particular side fortunate enough to catch the largest piece of vanilla crème.

They’re simple yet perfect cookies — one of Nabisco’s home runs.

“Why exactly does Nabisco suddenly need this many Oreo options?”


oreo-cookieSo, if these Oreo cookies were home runs for Nabisco, why is it operating the Oreo brand with so much fear these days?

The reason I pose this question is that, recently, Nabisco has made a barrage of variations to its classic Oreo cookie theme. Right now, the selection of Oreos in the supermarket no longer takes up a normal sized portion of the cookie shelf. They now consume the entirety of the shelf from floor to the ceiling. It seems like Nabisco is afraid we are going to forget all about the Oreo.

Honestly, who can forget about the Oreo cookie?

Here is just a small listing of the many new and unnecessary Oreo cookies now on the shelves:

Triple Double Chocolate
Spring Chocolate
Oreo Chocolate
Pure Milk Chocolate
Golden Double Stuff
Golden Uh-Oh with Chocolate Cream
Double Stuff Chocolate
Reduced Fat
Chocolate Fudge Sundae (The Limited Edition)
Chocolate Mint ’n Crème

Why exactly does Nabisco suddenly need this many Oreo options?

Take a look at Oreo’s webpage. In year’s past, its product line may have been entirely featured on one webpage. Now, Oreo has an astonishing six pages worth of products. This seems ridiculous to me.

What does this all mean?

Clearly, Nabisco is overextending the brand. To understand your brand means having the confidence to recognize what it is that you do well. In a shaky marketplace, it can be easy to forget that. Nabisco does the Double Stuff Oreo and Regular Oreo cookie really well. They should stick with that and do so confidently. Otherwise, it threatens to dilute the Oreo brand itself, if it’s not already. Think of how powerful of a brand Cheerios used to be until it had so many variations of it that the Cheerios brand has become basically meaningless.

Adding too many options only complicates our shopping experience and ultimately weakens the reasons we were attracted to the brand in the first place. Surely, Nabisco doesn’t want to do that.

See more posts in the following related categories: cookie brands Nabisco oreo Oreo brand


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Marketing during COVID-19: A primer

  Marketing during COVID-19   Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 6 April 2020 Marketing during COVID-19: A Primer So much is uncertain these days. And uncertainty often gives way to fear. That’s what many brands are feeling right now and why marketing...

NFL free agency at least provides a distraction

  NFL free agency   Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 March 2020 NFL free agency at least provides a distraction Things are certainly in a strange place. People continue to be holed up and will be for the foreseeable future. All the while, a crazy NFL...

Share This