Facebook isn’t to blame for the Facebook Live killer
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
19 April 2017
Facebook Live was simply the venue, not the cause
Few things have been more disturbing that the live feed of the Facebook Live killer in Cleveland. Something about the befuddled 74-year-old victim’s reaction as Steve Stephens explained he was going to kill him struck me hard.
Thankfully, a McDonalds employee recognized Stephens and notified authorities. Minutes later, Stephens killed himself when police arrived.
“To put that genie back in the bottle is simply wishful thinking and not helpful to solving the real problems of poverty, race and mental illness that create these hateful acts.”
Now that the nightmare is over (although not for the victim’s family), outrage is flooding social media over Facebook’s attempt to censor Facebook Live material that is downright evil. This isn’t the first time Facebook Live has broadcast this kind of material. A police shooting in Minnesota was streamed live. Three men in Sweden did the same while committing rape. And there have been others, including beatings and torture.
Is this the fault of Facebook?
Facebook Live isn’t going anywhere
No, it isn’t. Although, yes, stricter control of Facebook Live broadcasts would be welcome. But the genie is out of the bottle. Twitter and YouTube also feature live streams, considered to be exciting ways to get viewers.
Would have the criminals done their deeds if they couldn’t stream it live? That’s a difficult question. You could argue that the live aspect gives the perpetrators more notoriety and, therefore, greater motivation.
But this is akin to the argument that violent movies or video games give rise to greater violence. I don’t think it’s a one-to-one ratio. Millions of people watch violent movies, play disturbing video games or stream Facebook Live without hurting anyone. The criminals already had a tendency toward these violent acts.
In the face of unexplainable tragedy, we humans often look for blame. It’s the reason why conspiracy theories are so rampant in the light of, let’s say, 9/11 or landing on the moon. There must be an explanation for this unexplainable incident, they think. The US government allowing 9/11 to happen seems plausible to them. Facebook Live is to blame.
So before we all go apeshit over the role Facebook played here, a word of caution. Just because there was a venue for this heinous act does not mean that venue is to blame. We live in a world where everything is out there for everyone to see. To put that genie back in the bottle is simply wishful thinking and not helpful to solving the real problems of poverty, race and mental illness that create these hateful acts.
Ford Advertising Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 23 April 2018 Ford advertising. Find someone new. News that Ford advertising might be leaving advertising giant WPP rocks the advertising world. However, the agency with 49 offices across the world will be allowed...
Sheetz MTO Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 19 April 2018 Sheetz MTO process remains sloooooooow I lay it on pretty thick in a post on Sheetz some years ago. For purposes here, I am rescinding a portion of my prior analysis, yet offer up a new critique. You see,...
Amazon Best Buy Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 April 2018 Who wins the Amazon Best Buy partnership? The recently announced Amazon Best Buy partnership is not the kind of partnership where Best Buy is opening a store within a store on Amazon. Rather, this is a...