Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
24 January 2019
Best of GEICO ads highlighting the problem
There’s a whole lotta advertising entertainment showing lately on our televisions. GEICO is showing its greatest hits, attempting to prompt watchers into voting on their favorite GEICO ads of the past.
Oh, there’s the camel hoping everyone will recognize that today is Hump Day. There’s the caveman and the gecko. And the pig screaming, “Wee wee wee” all the way home.
Some of the GEICO ads are memorable. Many are funny. Go vote if you’re so inclined.
But they do nothing, and have never done anything, for the GEICO brand.
In the fact, the GEICO ads represent what is infecting so much of TV advertising today. They’re all entertainment with only a few actually doing the hard work of stealing market share.
They’re only useful in raising awareness. That’s the only place advertising for entertainment sake means something. Especially if the brand is embedded in the ad itself. (A few rarely are.)
“GEICO spends more than anybody, shelling out more than $1 billion on its GEICO ads. Just so you can be amused. But not switch carriers.”
But the GEICO ads don’t need to raise awareness. We all know who GEICO is. If you’re looking for car insurance, GEICO is probably in the considered set.
GEICO ads don’t steal market share
Yet, market share doesn’t change. For one thing, consumers rarely switch insurance companies. Switching is seen as cumbersome and pointless. Would it be any better with State Farm, Allstate or…GEICO?
So, to encourage consumers to switch to your brand, you must mean something emotional and different from the competition. And, right now, there is so little difference between the brands you couldn’t slip a piece of paper between them.
Could you make the argument that there’s a difference in tone between the brands? Not really. State Farm also adopts a humorous tone, whether it’s Aaron Rodgers and his clueless agent. Or She Sheds. Progressive has Flo and her ragtag team of losers. Allstate can be more serious with Dennis Haysbert but opts often for Mayhem.
Yet, market share doesn’t change. The car insurance category remains relatively stagnant. The brands are spending so much money on ads just to play defense.
GEICO spends more than anybody, shelling out more than $1 billion on its GEICO ads.
Just so you can be amused. But not switch carriers. So, yeah, chuckle at the spots. But the GEICO ads are worth nothing more than that. A chuckle.
Weight Watchers brand Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 February 2020 The Weight Watchers brand opens up For any dietary plan to work, it must align with your mental wiring. That’s why I was so initially intrigued by the Noom diet, until...
Goodyear brand Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 17 February 2020 Goodyear brand improves, but still lacks connection Whether you’re the Goodyear brand or any other brand of tire, you compete in a tough industry. One that’s a victim of its...
Commonlit Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 29 November 2016 Teachers — make use of commonlit, and right away at that I’ll proclaim this right away — commonlit is an exceptional tool for teachers. But I’ll get back to that in a moment. This past...