Beating Walmart. Can anyone do it?
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
9 March 2012
Beating Walmart. Not unbeatable
Beating Walmart is constantly on my mind. I was listening to NPR discussing a recent Walmart ad campaign that was positioned directly against the regional grocery market chain Harris Teeter on my way into the office one morning.
The ad, which featured a consumer shopping at Harris Teeter, then shopping at Walmart for the same items. It ended up saving the consumer about 10%. The discussion raised the question of how Harris Teeter can fight back when prices are so much lower at Walmart? The obvious assumption by NPR was that it certainly had to compete. Compete using something other than price. It raises the question of how to go about beating Walmart at their own game
NPR, looking for other ways Harris Teeter could stay competitive, had a guest to talk about what HT can do.
Those became the typical go-to list of category table stakes: Clean store, great service, etc. Those are all valuable areas for Harris Teeter to perfect. But, they act as a perfect demonstration of how marketing today very often confuses best practices with reasons to prefer. Alone these tactics won’t set the stage for beating Walmart.
Harris Teeter could be a case study in beating Walmart
Harris Teeter should certainly have exceptional customer service, and the cleaner the store the better.
But these are things that every competitor in the category should already be doing. They are also what consumers already expect. These are the table stakes for grocery stores. They simply allow the store to exist in the category. They do not, in themselves, build preference or set up beating Walmart.
Beating Walmart requires building preference
Harris Teeter can eliminate any effect from the Walmart ads by building preference for the brand.
Putting all of its efforts into its brand provides context for those best practices. Just think about it.
What is more important to a consumer, telling them you have a clean store? Or, understanding what they believe about themselves that makes a clean store more valuable than price? The latter is emotional.
Provide a context that can be used to frame everything else you do. Essentially, everything works together under a single, resonate idea, rather than as multiple separate “things.” Things only represent activities and it is important to not confuse activity with accomplishment.
State Farm Advertising Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 September 2019 The new State Farm advertising makes no sense There is some bad advertising and then there is State Farm advertising with Patrick Mahomes and Aaron Rodgers. The ad makes no...
Retail branding Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 17 September 2019 The irony of much of today’s retail branding Here’s an example of irony in retail branding. Cost Plus World Market, or as we generally coin it, “World Market,” stands at the peak of my...
Rebranding basics Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 16 September 2019 Ignore rebranding basics and you end up with the expected Even after all these decades of marketers discussing their profession, I still don’t understand how so many of them get...