Another retail casualty: the CEO of Stein Mart

Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share

29 September 2016

Another retail casualty: the CEO of Stein Mart

The retail industry is under siege, if you haven’t already noticed. Stores are closing, CEOs are leaving (being either fired or retired) and few know what to do in the battle against Amazon.

I have written plenty about this issue, maybe even more than you know. I am a regular contributor to RetailWire, which you can read about here. The single biggest question asked is, “Where do retailers go from here?”

Stein mart CEO resigns

The resignation of the Stein Mart CEO is another demonstration that retail is dying.



Many years ago they contacted me. Then they decided they did not need any help

The latest shoe to drop is the resignation of Stein Mart CEO Dawn Robertson, who left after same-stores sales declined 4% this past quarter.

You sense a trend here. Office Depot and Staples, once thought to be merger partners, are looking for new CEOs. Macy’s is closing stores even though it promoted a national holiday hiring day.

It’s a mess out there for retailers.

“What do retailers do now? They have to go back to the basics. Build a brand that actually stands for something, one that is different and better.

That better part is difficult, but the different part is what has befuddled them.”

The problems facing Stein Mart and others

The problems are two-fold for retailers, such as Stein Mart. First, they have never gotten the basic strategies of creating preference right. Secondly, they are behind the curve when it comes to online retailing.

Retailers were once powerful, thriving during the days when malls took over the marketplace. Malls were a community of stores, aping a downtown marketplace. Shopping at a mall was efficient and easy for buyers. Retailers reaped the rewards of shoppers buying more than they intended. (Think the Sam’s Club model. You go for a great deal, but stroll up to the checkout counter with loads of merchandise.)

The promise that they can save you.

But they are having trouble saving themselves.

In good times, brands often get lazy. They live off their success, thinking that there’s nothing they need to do to prepare for change.

So few, if any, actually built brand preference. Instead, retailers fought over price, some adopting the Walmart model of always having a low price with others holding sales every week (that’s what has gotten Stein Mart in trouble). When you do that, you teach audiences to shop on price because you haven’t given them any other reason to choose.

So shoppers choose Amazon.

That second issue, failing to be a strong presence online, caught retailers with their pants down. They were slow to prepare and any preference they did have disappeared. In essence, retailers have reaped what they sowed.

What do retailers do now? They have to go back to the basics. Build a brand that actually stands for something, one that is different and better. That better part is difficult, but the different part is what has befuddled them.

The retail choices all look, sound and, frankly, are the same. There’s not a squat of difference between Stein Mart and Kohl’s from the point of view of the customer.

No wonder we all shop on Amazon. At least we know what’s different there.


  1. Charlie

    Times are a changing’ … I think that was a phrase from a Dylan song, but it is so true. Malls are dying, shopping centers a nearly vacant. On-line buying rules retail now. I really don’t see it affecting food stores as much. People still have to see, smell, and feel food items. I remember back in the 70’s and early 80’s I worked in the grocery dept. of a member dept. store called Memco. Paid a buck, and you’re a card carrying member. Different than Sam’s Club or Costco. Store had different departments like Walmart, but on a smaller scale. The merchandise was of great quality as well. The grocery dept. was at the rear of each store. Produce and meat were great. Nothing sold in bulk like Costco. Maybe someone with some deep pockets might explore those ideas again.

  2. Beau Martin

    Isn’t Stienmart a fun shopping destination, one people choose for recreational shopping, like Starbucks or to a lesser degree like Costco, a place to go to get out?


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Video Advertising Bureau recommends crap

  Video Advertising Bureau   Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 18 October 2018 The Video Advertising Bureau recommends crap Can you sing the Wayfair jingle? The Video Advertising Bureau wants you to believe it’s so important.   "Is the future uncertain? Nope. It’s...


Stein Mart


Share This