Annies IPO could be troubling for its brand

Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share

28 March 2012

Could consumers see it now as owned by Wall Street?

Annies IPO that is sending investors into a frenzy, as Annie’s stock rose by as much as 70% from its IPO price. If you are not familiar with Annie’s, it is a producer of organic and natural foods with a promise of social responsibility. Started out of a house, Annie’s now has around 125 different products in 25,00 different retail outlets. Annie’s has a passionate and loyal following, and it seems that Annies IPO has initiated some passion from investors as well.

But what does an IPO like this mean to a brand like Annies?

“Becoming public has a way of diluting “causes” to the point where they offer the least amount of offense by casting the biggest to make projections and satisfy investors.”

“For more than 20 years, Annies has been nourishing families with simple, down-to-earth foods that taste great and are easy to love.  Annies is driven by a team of folks who are passionate about food, people, and the planet we all share. That’s why we’ve sought out the best ingredients Mother Earth has to offer, harvesting pure, natural flavors to make delicious foods every family can feel good about. 

Honest-to-goodness goodness is cooked up here.  “ – Excerpt from Annies website

The meaning of Annies IPO to consumers

Annies came from very humble beginnings and there were a lot of people who worked very hard to get it to this point. Further, Annies has prided itself on how it gets its ingredients and puts a lot of time and resources promoting and developing community-based sustainable and natural farming and gardening. It has worked hard in getting legislation passed to change food labeling and actively supports causes and individuals who share its beliefs.

One of the things that struck me is that ,in many ways, those who use and love Annies products seem to be the antithesis of a typical “Wall Street” type. Though premium in price, Annies never positioned itself as a business. It was more of a movement. Its positioning has always been around organic, natural, sustainable, and socially responsible –  terms not typically associated with big agribusiness. Up to now, Annies has successfully forged its own way based upon its beliefs and has not had to succumb to the pressures of being a publicly traded company, beholden to Wall Street for quarterly results.

Will that change who it is?

annies IPOIf you asked any of its executives, they would all vehemently say no. Truth be told, they shouldn’t allow any effect because Annies power is based on emotion, not dollars and cents.

However, experience says that going from private to public means the market will affect Annies. Becoming public has a way of diluting causes to the point where they offer the least amount of offense by casting the biggest to make projections and satisfy investors. Those tend to trump all.

Annies IPO will give it an influx of cash. Investors will want to see a return on that cash and the major investors will want to have a say in how that’s done. If Annies really cares about its brand and does not want to get swept up into the Nabisco or P&G mass production juggernaut, then it must take it very slowly in managing investor expectations and making its core customers comfortable with the transition.

Will investors be OK with a smaller return in cash for a larger return on social responsibility? It is a difficult balancing act naturally (no pun intended) tilted to the side with money. Annies, don’t lose the cause because it’s the emotional part of your business – and the most important.

Update: Since this post was published in 2012, Annies has been purchased by General Mills. Goodbye, causes?

See more posts in the following related categories: annie's brand Annie's IPO sustainable brands Wall Street


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This