Positioning Family Dollar (and others) for trouble ahead
Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share
14 October 2013
Family Dollar could have prepared for government shutdown
Last week’s remarks from Family Dollar CEO Howard Levine make sense. He said that the government shutdown is hurting those on government assistance – which make up more than half of Family Dollar’s customers. (And, logically, those of Dollar General and Dollar Tree as well.)
“Like most of the rebranding garbage out there, Belk ended up with a new logo and color palette and not much more (smells like politics to me).”
What interested me was his statement later, saying, “We have repositioned the company for the tough sales environment.”
That sounds good on paper. Business must always look ahead to trends and make adjustment. But that isn’t what has happened here, at least from the point of view of the customer. The chain is still “my family. my family dollar.”
First of all, that’s not new positioning and it’s redundant. (The name already says that.) But Family Dollar must believe its positioning works in this government crisis.
Would this positioning stave off lost market share in a long-term crisis? I don’t think so, which is why I suspect Mr. Levine is worried. You must position your brand so that it is so emotionally intensive that it succeeds regardless of the nation’s economic situation.
Recently, dollar stores have increased market share because of the general economic climate, and they do share a position that is different than the retail market. But they are not emotional brands, which means they are easily discarded.
Even Apple, with its expensive products, always succeeds no matter the economic climate because its brand is emotional.
My point is that, to “reposition the company for the tough sales environment,” you should do it before that environment comes to fruition by being about something bigger than something so literal. Be about something emotional. Then you are resistant to bad economic times.
Brand Blindnes is Brand Loyalty Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 27 April 2017 Brand loyalty and brand blindness Did you know that brand loyalty is a form of brand blindness? Even though most of us believe we act rationally, self-identification is a form of...
ESPN layoffs next step to its doom? Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 26 April 2017 ESPN layoffs demonstrate lack of vision The ESPN layoffs announced today came as no surprise. But it still hurts to see good people let go. The number of layoffs and length of tenure...
Research mistakes are preventable Tom Dougherty, CEO - Stealing Share 25 April 2017 Research mistakes. No excuses. Making research mistakes is easier than ever. And these blunders can mangle and mislead brands. Especially brands that are looking for opportunities to...