The Confederate Flag at Washington and Lee University

Tom Dougherty, CEO – Stealing Share

29 November 2016

Confederate Flag at Washington and Lee

Was the Confederate Flag(s) that adorned the Lee Chapel as offensive as the South Carolina Flag?

With all the turmoil over the Confederate Flag in South Carolina (which I make an argument for its removal) I think it is important to look at what happened recently at Washington and Lee University.

Here political correctness stripped the General’s Memorial of his Army’s flags in the banal service of political correctness.

What is the brand of Washington and Lee University? Does it have anything to do with the Confederate Flag?

August 2017 update.

Brand is dynamic. It must adjust to market changes and reflect the beliefs of the marketplace. I have written broadly about my prejudice against removing civil was statues and memorials.

This reflects my obsession with history. And, my upset at how we teach history today. You will find blogs I have written about Washington and Lee University, civil war statues and even the usurpation of Armistice Day by Veterans Day. Today I am stating clearly that aside from memorials in Civil War Battlefields and at grave sites, I want to go on record as supporting the removal of these monuments and placing them in museums where context seeks to remove the usurping of these historical figures by white supremacists, Neo-Nazi groups and Klan members.

For me, Charlottesville has changed the fabric of my historical arguments. The meaning these monuments and flags have for me, as a historian, changed. Move them. Put them in museums where they form part of an historical lesson and not the rallying point for disgraceful and violent groups.-— Tom

The Confederate Battle Flag. Not the Bonnie Blue Flag of the Confederacy.

It is too bad this flag was hijacked by modern racists

This is a tough call. Is it history or racism? I do not know how a University that is named after General Robert E Lee can walk away from his battle flag.

I realize that symbols carry great power and can excite great emotions.

To my thinking, the lee Chapel is a museum of sorts. A place where the General’s remains lie so it should come to no one’s surprise that a few of the battle flags surround his memorial.

Here we were faced with a choice — Should the university try to downplay the history of its roots or the deep feelings of its current students? I believe that there are two valid sides to this argument, but history has been written.

“To my thinking, the lee Chapel is a museum of sorts. A place where the General’s remains lie so it should come to no one’s surprise that a few of the battle flags surround his memorial.”

The University was misguided

If the University needs to distance themselves from Robert. E Lee then they should consider removing his name from the school itself and not just the Confederate Flag.

His name was, after all, added after the Confederate General’s death to what was then Washington College. It is a slippery slope here. George Washington held slaves too.

Sadly, from my point of view the University bowed to the pressure of its politically correct students and decided to remove the Confederate flag.

This is a tragedy in my mind. Not just for historians but for the University itself. Washington and Lee has no idea what its brand is all about.

If you are interested in what the fuss was all about, take a look. What you see in the Lee Chapel is a statue of Lee recalling in the battlefield (no it is not a statue of Lee after death) designed by Edward Valentine. On each side you will see a few of the Confederate Battle Flags.

General Lee after the war, Posing for Mathew Brady.

The photo was colorized. No such technology existed in 1865.

Directly below this recumbent statue, in a crypt, General lee is buried along with his wife Mary Anna Randolph Custis (great-granddaughter of Martha Washington) and his father Light Horse Harry Lee, his mother and Lee’s seven children.

Traveler, his famous horse was reentered and buried outside the entrance to the General’s office.

It is not as if the Chapel was festooned with flags or sat atop a seat of government (like the South Carolina Capitol).

This is a solemn place and a memorial to an American (lee was granted his citizenship by President Gerald Ford in 1975. It is worth a read here to understand the circumstances of his amnesty. 

1 Comment

  1. Richard mcpherson

    What a shame to remove the flags ,how about the American flag that brought the slaves,how about the Indians who lost everything under the american flag …..here is your racist flag.lincoln could have averted it. Emancipation might have been delayed, but it would have come I the natural way of events, without the loss of a single man or a single dollar .a total upward of a million lives and a. Estimated long run of 20 million dollars lincolns real gift of posterity mr Lincoln stands in history as one who did more evil than any man known to the world . Why is the human race so ignorant? Let’s take down Mount Rushmore 3 of these men were slave holders. Do what you will you cant erase history ,if you don’t want to see the flags don’t go where you know they are ………

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This