Tom Dougherty Comments to The Denver Post

Tom Dougherty on Mutual Funds for The Denver Post

Scandal may aid smaller funds, but don’t expect marketing push. “For one, those traits are assumed, not marketed”, said Tom Dougherty…


Scandal may aid smaller funds but don’t expect a marketing push

by Aida Svaldi Business Writer

 What is your opinion on the mutual funds scandal?

Tom Dougherty on Mutual FundsFor one, those traits are assumed, not marketed, said Tom Dougherty, a strategist with Stealing Share, a brand consulting firm in Greensboro, N.C. ‘I would be careful about pretending to be the good guy unless your brand has permission to do that,’ Dougherty said.

About the only fund groups that can pull that off are socially responsible mutual funds, he said. Also, Americans are conditioned to expect anyone who brags too loudly about their virtue to fall, he said. ‘We aren’t marketing anything like that,’ said Cynthia Crossland, marketing director for Meridian Investment Management and the Icon Funds in Greenwood Village.

Mutual funds have historically built their reputation on investment strategy, money management talent and most of all performance. Icon, whose funds are handily outperforming larger competitors, including Janus, plans to stay on that track, she said.

View our market study on Mutual Funds here

The Battle for market share in the Mutual Fund Industry

Mutual Fund Market Study

By Tom Dougherty

Mutual fund market study chart of the current categoryThe mutual fund industry markets itself by the investment philosophy that it is unnecessary to observe the market by brand name. To make matters worse, funds have tried to differentiate (brand) themselves by using independent rating systems like Morningstar. This is akin to differentiating your brand of beer by saying that it is “liquid and sells for XYZ price.”

no mutual fund market study would be complete without considering morningstarDuring the huge run-up to mutual fund investing in the 1990’s, this model seemed effective. The market was running great guns, and everyone’s Morningstar rating showed double digit growth. Some investment experts were actually encouraging investors to compare Morningstar ratings and “trade” funds on an annual basis. 2014Lipper_Awards_logo_368x235As a result of basing the brand value on performance, the market from the inside-out shows that the only choice for the investor is for portfolio diversification between growth and value or domestic and international. Lipper was no better. In each case preference was going to be built around past performance and this led many funds to experience drift. However, the only reason to have a brand is to create margins or increase preference.

Mutual Funds.002In a mutual fund market study, it is clear to see that if your product or service is being purchased as a result of performance, you have no brand and no connection with the customer. No one noticed the dangerously rising tides during the exuberance of the 90s — and eventually found themselves without any brand equity. The result of this lack of security and protection: the flight of investor assets.

If we look at the market from the outside-in (from the perspective of the investor) it is possible to see the market in very different terms. But mutual fund families must begin to position the family of funds and not the individual instruments.

Mutual fund market study chart showing opportunity
Position your fund around the emotional connections of the target audience

In other words, the brand should reflect the brandface of the segmented target market. One possible way to see the market is from the perspective of investor lifestyle. This perspective shows great opportunity for fund families to define their brand in a way that resonates with investors. It works in two ways. First, it tells the target audience who the family of funds is for, and secondly, it satisfies the need to “make it easy for me.” No brand of mutual fund, with the possible exception of the socially conscious funds, has done this sort of brand segmentation.

 CEO Tom Dougherty was featured in the Denver Post as an expert on mutual funds

How Financial Services can win in a recession

Read a market study on banking