• About Tom Dougherty

    Tom Dougherty CEO, Stealing Share

    Tom Dougherty is the President and CEO of Stealing Share, Inc., and has helped national and global brands such as Lexus, IKEA and Tide steal market share over his 25-year career.

    An often-quoted source on business and brands, he has been featured recently by the New York Times and CNN, discussing topics ranging from television to Apple to airlines.

    Tom also regularly speaks at conferences as a keynote and break-out speaker. To find out more on inviting him to your speaking engagement and view a video of him speaking, click here.

    You can also reach him via email attomd@stealingshare.com.

    Follow me on Twitter

Tom Brady and the culture of cheating

There are more scenarios to play out for final judgment, but it sure is becoming difficult to believe that Tom Brady didn’t direct balls to be deflated for last season’s AFC Championship Game and that he did cooperate with the ensuing investigation.

That’s where were are at the moment with Deflategate.

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell upheld the four-game suspension after Brady’s appeal, charging the NFL star with destroying his cell phone the day before or the day of him being questioned by investigators.

It's getting hard to believe Brady.
It’s getting hard to believe Brady.

That’s the main sticking point when it comes, not in federal court where the players’ union will sue the NFL over the appeal process, but in the court of public opinion. The NFL said “Mr. Brady knew about, approved of, consented to, and provided inducements and rewards” to equipment managers to deflate the balls. That means the phone was evidence and the timing of its destruction is suspicious at best.

Brady says he always destroys his old phone when he gets a new one (he switched from an Android to an iPhone 6, so he’s acquired good taste). But the timing makes that hard to believe. (And the NFL says that Brady still has an older phone he didn’t destroy.)

Once the lawyers have had it (and who knows how long that process will take), many of us will start to wonder about the brand of Tom Brady. I’m not talking legacy because I still see this as a minor offense and I believe Brady is one of the greatest quarterbacks ever, regardless.

But the story of Tom Brady has always had its underdog charm. He shared the QB position in college with a baseball prospect, was drafted alarmingly low (sixth round) by the New England Patriots, become the Lou Gehrig to Drew Bledsoe’s Wally Pip by winning four Super Bowls and married a supermodel.

That’s the American dream, isn’t it?

Where we go from here.

Now, with the shadow of Spygate (the Patriots were penalized for filming opponents’ signals in 2007), we wonder if Brady and the Patriots foster a culture of cheating. For the fanatic anti-Patriot fan, that’s a no-brainer yes.

For the rest of us, who fall in the middle, there will always be that cloud of suspicion, whether Brady wins the lawsuit or not. The damage has been done.

We probably expect our sport idols to be perfect too much and for them to ignore their competitive nature when we deem it appropriate. But if the brand of Tom Brady (and the New England Patriots) is shadowy, then to repair the brand means being the opposite of that. To be transparent.

Brady has responded on Facebook, refuting the NFL’s claims, but it doesn’t quite hold water. (For one thing, the explanation for destroying the phone is hard to believe.)

The courts will take over now but it would behoove Brady, if he is interested in repairing his public image (and he may not), to be candid, open and honest. He will no doubt be lawyered up for the moment, but he’s still got some work to do.

One thought on “Tom Brady and the culture of cheating

  1. I honestly don’t care for Brady. I am not a fan – but I am really struggling with using the word”cheating” when it comes to inflate gate. All teams look for a competitive edge. I also wonder just how many other infractions occur on a weekly basis on the NFL field? Many – I assume. Skilled linemen “hold” constantly. You don’t see press conferences as a result. Besides the fact air pressure in footballs I am sure changes on an hourly basis. This infraction is almost silly. If making sure the proper pressure was such a huge issue because someone had a HUGE advantage – refs would be there with hand held meters every 15 mins. I am not a seasoned PR person but it just seems like it would be to the Patriots advantage to get this out of the media as soon as possible. Just let it go and move on. Stop protesting and take a bullet. Make a firm statement denying this accusation and start thinking about double sessions in August. The more they talk and deny and wave the unfair flag – the worse it gets. Brady (if innocent) has a way to silence the accusers. Contact his telephone provider and ask for a transcript of his texts before the week, during, and after. The end. His $1200 an hour lawyers must know this – if I do??!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *